@ Pop Syndicate-- Captain America: Who Will Wield the Shield?
So Captain America: Reborn isn't even done yet but we're already living in a pre-Siege world so Marvel had to get this book out now:
"Looking at the themes that Brubaker has been exploring in Captain America, Who Will Wield the Shield? should work a lot better than it actually does. After the sensationalism of his post-Civil War stories, Brubaker should be able to get back to focusing on shared struggles of Rogers and Barnes. He does here but it comes off as too packaged and manufactured. In one issue, Brubaker has to establish and answer their struggle—who will get to keep the costume and shield and who what will the future hold for the one left without an identity in the end. That should be a bigger story… No, that is the bigger story and it’s been the story that Brubaker has been telling so why now that he has both characters back, does it get addressed and ended so quickly?"
You can read the full review at Pop Syndicate. Below is an uncolored page from this book (and you can see some more here.) I absolutely love the way Guice put this page together. There's fantastic emotion and energy on this page as it's more about what's unsaid between the characters than what is said. The 4th panel, with Cap shadowboxing just shows how antsy he is on the snowy night, how unsure he is about what to do. I really wish that Guice had been able to draw the whole book because once Luke Ross takes over, there's a horrible shift in the nature of the art, where Ross is more concerned about the figures and the action than he is about the mood and subtext of the story. 
